Glaciation of Siberia and the problem of massive ice beddings


https://doi.org/10.15356/2076-6734-2017-4-527-542

Full Text:




Abstract

As a result of many years of the author’s studies of glaciers and ground ices, a great amount of factual material has been collected for a purpose to analyze a possibility of burying the glaciers in the permafrost zone and to esti‑ mate a time of their stay in such а condition. According to the author’s opinion, the Siberian glaciers were mainly the valley ones; ice sheets were never formed, and any existence of buried glaciers could not be real in the geo‑ logical time scale. However, some researchers still believe that in the Quaternary ice sheets occurred in the North of Siberia, and, in addition, they consider the local massive ice beddings as relics of these sheets. No clear expla‑ nation of the similar origin of such ice structures exists at the present time, so development and variety of this ice could be easier explained by the permafrost genesis. Basing on results of observations carried out in all glacier regions of Siberia, the author concludes that glaciers cannot exist in the form of buried ice for a long time. This is unrealistic even in the North‑East of Siberia, where the absolute minimum temperature is −67.8 °C, and the mean annual air temperature drops below −17 °C. The characteristic feature of the Siberia continental climate is short, but hot summer. In such a situation, the coarse fragmental morainic material, covering glaciers by the layer up to 3 m thick, cannot preserve the underlying ice from melting because the heat penetrates down with the air, liquid precipitation, and the melt water. When glaciers reduce, the dead ice, buried under a moraine, may be preserved in the coldest areas of Siberia for only 100–150 years. Therefore, despite the resemblance of the scarps of the ice bodies having the permafrost or glacial origin, consideration of them as relics of ancient glaciers would be wrong.

About the Author

V. S. Sheinkman
Earth Cryosphere Institute of the Tyumen Research Center, Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Tyumen State University; Tyumen Industrial University.
Russian Federation
Tyumen.


References

1. Karpov E.G. Podzemnye l’dy Yeniseyskogo Severa. Underground ice of the North Yenisei area. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1986: 134 p. [In Russian].

2. Kuznetsova T.P., Karpov E.G. Usloviya formirovaniya ledomineral’nogo kompleksa Ledyanoy gory. Conditions of forming the ice-mineral complex of the Ledyanaya Gora (Ice Hill). Yakutsk: Institute of Permafrost, Siberian Branch, RAS, 1989: 172 p. [In Russian].

3. Sheinkman V.S., Melnikov V.P. Ledniki Sibiri kak komponent kriolitogenno-glyatsial’nykh geosistem. Glaciers of Siberia as a component of cryogenic-glacial geosystems. Kriosfera Zemli. Earth’s Cryosphere. 2014, XVIII (2): 3–23. http://www.izdatgeo.ru (In Russian).

4. Sheinkman V.S., Plyusnin V.M. Oledenenie severa Zapadnoy Sibiri: spornye voprosy i puti ikh resheniya. Glaciation of NorthWestern Siberia: discussion questions and ways for their solution. Led i Sneg. Ice and Snow. 2015, 1 (129): 103–120. doi:10.15356/IS.2015.01.09. [In Russian].

5. Sheinkman V.S. Quaternary glaciation in North-Western Siberia – New evidence and interpretation. Quaternary International. 2016, 420: 15–23. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2015.11.147.

6. Pidoplichko I.G. O lednikovom periode. About the Glacial Period. V. 1. Kiev: Academy of Sciences of the Ukrainian SSR, 1946: 171 p. [In Russian].

7. Grosvald M.G. Arktika v posledniy lednikoviy maksimum i v golotsene – okeanskie vybrosy i morskie l’dy, ikh dvizhenie i svyaz’ s klimatom. Arctic during the Last Glacial maximum and Holocene – ocean discharges, continental and sea ice, their movement and relationship with climate. Materialy glatsiologicheskikh issledovaniy. Data of Glaciological Studies. 2004, 96: 47–54. [In Russian].

8. Kaplyanskaya F.A., Tarnogradskiy V.D. Glatsial'naya geologiya Glaсial geology. Leningrad: Nedra, 1993: 328 p. [In Russian].

9. Solomatin V.I. Fizika i geografiya podzemnogo oledeneniya. Physics and geography of underground glaciation. Novosibirsk: Geo, 2013. 346 p. [In Russian].

10. Voeikov A.I. Klimaticheskie usloviya lednikovykh yavleniy, nastoyashchikh i proshedshikh. Climatic conditions of modern and past glacial phenomena. Zapiski Mineralogicheskogo Obshchestva. Transections of Mineralogical Society. Ser. 2. Pt. 16. SanktPetersburg, 1881: 21–90. [In Russian].

11. Obruchev V.A. Priznaki lednikovogo perioda v Severnoy i Tsentral’noy Azii. Showings of the Glacial Period in North and Central Asia. Izbrannye raboty po geografii Azii. Selected works on geography of Asia. V. 3. Moscow: Geografgiz, 1951: 49–128. [In Russian].

12. Cherskiy I.D. K voprosu o sledakh drevnikh lednikov v Vostochnoy Sibiri. To the question on evidence of ancient glaciers in Eastern Siberia. Izvestia Vostochno-Sibirskogo otdela Imperatorskogo Russkogo Geograficheskogo obshchestva. Transactions of the East-Siberian Branch of the Imperial Russian Geographical Society. 1882, 12 (4–5): 28–62. [In Russian] .

13. Feldman G.M. Prognoz temperaturnogo rezhima gruntov i razvitiya kriogennykh protsessov. Prognosis of ground temperature regime and development of cryogenic processes. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1977: 190 p. [In Russian].

14. Vasiliev I.S. Zakomernosti sezonnogo protaivaniya gruntov v Vostochnoy Yakutii. Regularities of seasonal thawing the grounds in Eastern Yakutia. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1982: 136 p. [In Russian].

15. Kotsebu O.E. Puteshestviya vokrug sveta. Travels around the world. Moscow: Drofa, 2011: 966 p. [In Russian].

16. Figurin A.E. Izvlechenie iz zapisok mediko-khirurga Figurina, vedennykh vo vremya opisi beregov Severo-Vostochnoy Sibiri. Extract from the notes of medical surgeon Figurin, carried out during description of North-Eastern Siberian coast. Zapiski Rossiyskogo Admiralteystva. Transactions of Russian Admiralty. V. 5. Sankt-Petersburg, 1825: 259–328. [In Russian].

17. Lopatin I.A. Nekotorye svedeniya o ledyanykh sloyakh Vostochnoy Sibiri. Some data about ice layers in Eastern Siberia. Prilozhenie № 1 k XXIX tomu Zapisok Imperatorskoy Akademii Nauk. Attachment № 1 to the XXIX volume of Transaction of Imperial Academy of Sciences. Sankt-Petersburg, 1876: 3–32. [In Russian].

18. Toll’ E.V. Iskopaemye ledniki Novosibirskikh ostrovov, ikh otnoshenie k trupam mamontov i k lednikovomu periodu. Fossil glaciers of Novosibirsk Islands, their relationship with mammoth corpses and the glacial period. Zapiski Imperatorskogo Russkogo Geograficheskogo obshchestva. Transactions of the Imperial Russian Geographical society. 1897, XXXII (1): 130–152. [In Russian].

19. Sumgin M.I. Vechnaya merzlota pochvy v predelakh SSSR. Permafrost of soils in the bounds of the USSR. Vladivostok: Far East Geophysical Observatory, 1927: 369 p. [In Russian].

20. Vtyurin B.I. Podzemnye l’dy SSSR. Ground ice of the USSR. Moscow: Nauka, 1975: 215 p. [In Russian].

21. Gasanov S.S. Sintez kriolitologicheskogo znaniya. Synthesis of cryolithological knowledge. Moscow: Nauka, 1984: 88 p. [In Russian].

22. Popov A.I. Merzlotnye yavleniya v zemnoy kore (kriolitologiya). Permafrost phenomena in the Earth crust (cryolithology). Moscow: MSU, 1967: 304 p. [In Russian].

23. Shumskiy P.A. Osnovy strukturnogo ledovedeniya. Foundation of structural ice knowledge. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences, 1955: 492 p. [In Russian].

24. Bol’shiyanov D.Y. Passivnoe oledenenie Arktiki i Antarktidy. Passive glaciation of Arctic and Antarctica. Sankt-Petersburg: AARI, 2006: 296 p. [In Russian].

25. Dubikov G.I. Sostav i kriogennoe stroenie merzlykh tolshch Zapadnoy Sibiri. Composition and cryogenic structure of permafrost in Western Siberia. Moscow: GEOS, 2002: 248 p. [In Russian].

26. Koreisha M.M., Khimenkov A.N., Bryksina G.S. O proiskhozhdenii plastovykh zalezhei podzemnogo l’da na severe Zapadnoy Sibiri. On origin of bedding ice bodies in the North of Western Siberia. Materialy glatsiologicheskikh issledovaniy. Data of Glaciological Studies. 1981, 41: 62–66. [In Russian].

27. Mackay J.R. The origin of massive ice beds in permafrost; Western Arctic Coast, Canada. Canadian Journ. of Earth Science. 1971, 8 (4): 397–422.

28. Plastovye l’dy kriolitozony. Bedding ice of cryolithozone. Ed. A .I. Popov. Yakutsk: Institute of Permafrost, 1982: 140 p. [In Russian].

29. Gusev E.F., Kostin D.A., Markina N.V., Rekant P.V., Sharin V.V., Dorechkina D.E., Zarkhidze D.V. Problemy kartirovaniya i geneticheskoy interpretatsii chetvertichnykh otlozheniy arkticheskogo shelfa Rossii (po materialam GGK41000/3). Problems of mapping and genetic interpretation of Quaternary deposits in the Russian Arctic shelf (on the material of GGK41000/3). Regionalnaya geologiya i metallogeniya. Regional geology and metallogeny. 2012, 50: 5–14. [In Russian].

30. Kuzin I.L. Geomorfologiya Zapadno-Sibirskoy ravniny. Geomorphology of the West-Siberian Plane. Sankt-Petersburg, Edition of the Government Polar Academy, 2005: 176 p. [In Russian].

31. Vasil’chuk А.К., Vasil’chuk Y.K. Palinologicheskaya indikatsiya negletchernogo proiskhozhdeniya plastovykh l’dov. Palynological indication of non-glacier origin of bedding ice bodies. Inzhenernaya geologia. Engineering Geology. 2010, 1: 24–38. [In Russian].

32. Koreysha M.M. Sovrenennoe oledenenie khrebta Suntar-Khayata. Modern glaciation of Suntar-Khayata Range. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences, 1963: 170 p. [In Russian].

33. Shpolyanskaya N.A. Pleistotsen-golotsenovaya istoriya razvitiya kriolitozony Rossiyskoy Arktiki glazami podzemnykh l’dov. Pleistocene–Holocene history of permafrost development of Russian Arctic by eyes of underground ice. Moscow–Izhevsk: Institute of Computer Studies. 2015: 370 p. [In Russian].

34. Lavrushin Yu.A. Stroenie i formirovanie moren materikovykh oledeneniy. Structure and formation of continental glaciations. Moscow: Nauka, 1976: 237 p. [In Russian].

35. Paterson W.S.B. Fizika lednikov. The physics of glaciers. Moscow: Mir, 1984: 473 p. [In Russian].

36. Serebryaniy L.R., Orlov A.V., Solomina O.N. Moreny – istochnik glyatsiologicheskoy informatsii. Moraines are issues of glaciological information. Moscow: Nauka, 1989: 236 p. [In Russian].

37. Boulton G.S. Theory of glacial erosion, transport and deposition as a consequence of subglacial sediment deformation. Journ. of Glaciology. 1996, 42 (140): 43–62.

38. Chuvardinskiy V.G. Rezultaty skvoznogo razburivaniya lednikovykh pokrovov Arktiki I Antarktidy i ikh znachenie dlya resheniya problem chetvertichnogo perioda. Results of through drilling the Arctic and Antarctic ice sheets and their signification for solving of problems of the Quaternary. Izvestiya RGO. Transactions of Russian Geographical Society. 2012, 144 (2): 28–41. [In Russian].

39. Talalay P.G. Subglacial till and bedrock drilling. Cold Regions Science and Technology. 2013, 86: 142–166. doi:10.1016/j.coldregions.2012.08.009.

40. Evteev S.A. Geologicheskaya deyatel’nost’ lednikovogo pokrova Vostochnoy Antarktidy. Geologic activity of the East Antarctic Ice Sheet. Moscow: Nauka, 1964: 120 p. [In Russian].

41. Tronov M.V. Ocherki oledeneniya Altaya. Essays on the Altai glaciation. Moscow: Geografgiz, 1949: 376 p. [In Russian].

42. Sapozhnikov V.V. Puti po Russkomu Altayu. Rotes across Russian Altai. Tomsk: Tipo-litografiya Sibirskogo Tovarishchestva pechatnogo dela. Printing and lithographic house of Siberian partnership of print business, 1912: 169 p. [In Russian].

43. Bierman P.R., Corbett L.B., Graly J.A., Neumann T.A., Lini A., Crosby B.T., Rood D.H. Preservation of a preglacial landscape under the center of the Greenland Ice Sheet. Science. 2014, 344: 402–405. doi:10.1126/science.1249047.

44. Glatsiologiya Shpitsbergena. Glaciology of Svalbard. Ed. S .A. Zhhitnikova. Мoscow: Nauka, 1985: 200 p. [In Russian].

45. Markov A.N. Geologo-geofizicheskaya model sloistoy struktury i dinamiki lednikovogo pokrova Antarktidy. Geologicalgeophysical model of laminated structure and dynamics of Eastern-Antarctic ice sheet. PhD thesis. St .-Petersburg Plekhanov State Geol. Institute. СПб ., 2009. 20 p. [In Russian].


Supplementary files

For citation: Sheinkman V.S. Glaciation of Siberia and the problem of massive ice beddings. Ice and Snow. 2017;57(4):527-542. https://doi.org/10.15356/2076-6734-2017-4-527-542

Views: 863

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2076-6734 (Print)
ISSN 2412-3765 (Online)